rap.frhiphop.fron air
✨ SubscriptionSign up
RAP.FR
Martina McBride - Everlasting
Chronique d'album

Martina McBride - Everlasting

Editorial note6,5/ 10
By Le Stagiaire·

Everlasting marks a vast stretching exercise for Martina McBride, her twelfth studio album released on April 8, 2014 through her own label. This record ventures resolutely into the soul and R&B repertoires, moving away from the usual country horizons that have marked key milestones like Eleven (2011) or Timeless. The production, by Don Was, builds a warm and intimate sonic architecture without sacrificing polish, offering a soundscape where the artist's voice becomes the primary vehicle for a stylistic evolution.

A triumphant entry into the new soul vein

The album opens with track 1, Do Right Woman, Do Right Man, a cover of a classic that immediately serves as the entry point into this new soul vein. This first listen sets the tone for a project where the selection of tracks is judged brilliant by some observers, transforming a concept sometimes considered overdone into a collection that shines. The instrumental arrangement includes a variety of instruments such as trumpets and a captivating organ, creating an intimate atmosphere that allows the singer to skillfully challenge a handful of pop, soul, and blues tracks. The track closes the album with To Know Him Is to Love Him, thus sealing a structural loop around the great standards.

Don Was's production: Meticulous and sometimes sugary sound quality

Beyond the artists' names, Don Was' contribution remains central to defining the overall atmosphere. However, this warm approach has its limits: some critics note that the result can sometimes resemble overly sweet tea, a tension between the desired intimacy and the richness of the arrangements. Tracks like Wild Night, Come See About Me, Little Bit of Rain, I've Been Loving You Too Long, What Becomes of the Brokenhearted, and If You Don't Know Me by Now navigate through this production, demonstrating a sonic density that keeps the listening experience engaging without ever becoming monotonous.

A critical assessment between success and a sometimes overdone concept

The entire project, hosted by the label Martina McBride, revolves around a creative "stretching" ambition validated by critics such as Gary Graff, who describe the approach as a successful and welcome exercise. The overall reception confirms this dual nature: Stephen Thomas Erlewine finds a soothing warmth in it, while Jerry Shriver of USA Today highlights how a daring choice manages to overcome the usual reservations associated with the genre. Beyond the notable collaborations with Gavin DeGraw and Kelly Clarkson, it is the album's ability to navigate between intimacy and refinement that makes it strong, creating an atmosphere where the sonic density maintains the listening experience without ever becoming monotonous, thus offering a quality described as great, warm, and intimate, without ever sacrificing technical brilliance. The assessment of this album is complex, oscillating between a generally positive reception and reservations about the nature of the project. Gary Graff of The Oakland Press noted that it was a successful and welcome creative exercise, while Stephen Thomas Erlewine highlighted the presence of warmth in Was's production. However, the critique also pointed out that covering soul hits is a clichéd concept, even though this well-chosen collection ultimately shines through. Overall, it offers a sound quality described as great, warm, and intimate, without sacrificing polish, according to Jon Freeman of Country Weekly.

Technical specifications

- Release date: April 8, 2014 - Label : Martina McBride - Tracks : 12 - Opening / closing : Do Right Woman, Do Right Man / To Know Him Is to Love Him - Guests : Gavin DeGraw, Kelly Clarkson - Previous album : The Classic Christmas Album (2013)

🎬 The album's music videos

14 clips · continuous playback

Tracks

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14

🔥 The tracks that are blowing up

Hip-Hop/R&B ranking · week of 16/11/2026

  1. 1I Just Might— Bruno Mars
  2. 2Janice STFU— Drake
  3. 3What You Need— Tems
  4. 4Dead Fresh— Lil Baby
  5. 5So Good— Jhene Aiko Featuring Kendrick Lamar
  6. 6WTF GOIN— Belly Gang Kushington & 21 Savage
  7. 7Solar Eclipse— Drake & Don Toliver
  8. 8AH HA— Cardi B
  9. 9Cold Shoulder— Drake, Don Toliver & Yebba
  10. 10Quebec— Drake

Review published on 16/11/2026 · Reviews

© 2026 rap.fr — All rights reserved.

More reviews